2025 Store Hours
Allergens
Employment
Gallery
Order Online
Shipping
Wedding
Wedding Cake Gallery
Weddings Through the Decades
Information
Trailside Event Center
About Us / Contact
Contact
Custom Cake Request
About Us & FAQs
Menu
Established in 1861, Trefzger’s Bakery is proud to be Central Illinois’ oldest bakery!
2025 Store Hours
Allergens
Employment
Gallery
Order Online
Shipping
Wedding
Wedding Cake Gallery
Weddings Through the Decades
Information
Trailside Event Center
About Us / Contact
Contact
Custom Cake Request
About Us & FAQs
×
Filter: Cookies
All
Bread
Breakfast Pastries
Cakes
Cookies
Cupcakes
Pies and Sweets
Seasonal
Thumbprint Shipping Box - Shipped
from $44.19
Easter Bunny Cookies (Seasonal)
$21.30
Easter Egg Cookies (Seasonal)
$14.00
BIG Chocolate Chip Cookies with Deco
$3.25
Special Border Sugar Cookies
from $11.40
Coconut Macaroons
from $12.00
Wheat-Free Thumbprint Cookies
$16.00
Everyday Cookies
$10.00
Iced Cookies
$12.00
Our Famous Thumbprint Cookies - Pickup Only
$12.00
Peanut Butter Thumbprint Cookies
$14.00
Handcut Cookies with Easter Sprinkles (Seasonal)
$12.00
Easter Basket Thumbprint Cookies (Seasonal)
$14.00
Specialty Border Cookies with Easter PhotoScans (Seasonal)
$17.40
Fancy Flower Cookies
$14.00
Handcut Cookies with Buttercream Icing and Crystal Sugar
$12.00
Scotch Cookies
$14.00
Iced Pumpkin Cookies (Seasonal)
from $7.00
sold out
Iced Ghost Cookies (Seasonal)
from $7.00
sold out
Machine Cut Iced Cookies
from $6.00
Gingerbread Cookies (Seasonal)
from $3.00
sold out
Turkey Shaped Cookies (Seasonal)
from $7.00
sold out
Football Shaped Cookies (Seasonal)
from $7.00
sold out
Special Border Photoscan Cookies
from $17.40
Coconut Macaroon Shipping Box - Shipped
$48.00
Super Bowl Machine Cut Cookies
from $7.00
sold out
Coffee Cake Shipping Box - Shipped
from $33.00
Springerles Shipping Box - Shipped (December Only)
from $32.00
sold out
Cookie Boxes and Trays
from $14.99
Heart Shaped Cookies (Seasonal)
$14.00
sold out
Graduation Machine Cut Cookies with Sprinkles
$14.00
Cinnamon Rolls Shipping Box - Shipped
$40.00
Graduation Machine Cut Cookies with Glitter
$14.00
CUSTOM COLORS - Our Famous Thumbprint Cookies
$14.00
Irish Bread Shipping Box - Shipped (Seasonal)
from $26.00
sold out
School Logo Photoscan Cookies
from $28.80
Chocolate Thumbprints with Buttercream Icing
$14.00
Piped Cross Cookies
from $11.70
School Logo Cupcakes
$27.00
Super Bowl Border PhotoScan Cookies
from $17.40
sold out
Medical Deco Cookies
from $20.40
Fondant Football Sugar Cookies
from $13.50
sold out
Graduation Cookies
from $20.40
Turtle Candy Shipping Box - Shipped
$31.25